Case Study of a Northridge Welded Steel Moment-Frame Building Having Severed Columns

The two-story welded steel moment-frame (WSMF) essential services building had columns severed by the 1994 Northridge earthquake. Two of eight columns suffered fracture across both flanges and panel zones in the WSMFs oriented in the north-south direction. Building and connection damage are described; computer models of the building are formulated and used in a damage correlation exercise that aids in damage interpretation; and a calibrated model is used as the basis of special studies. Factors contributing to the severed columns appear to be column-steel low-fracture toughness, panel zone detailing, and panel-zone shear yielding. Using FEMA-351 guidelines, the as-built as well as the Northridge-damaged structure pass the global collapse prevention drift criterion and fail the local collapse prevention drift criterion. The results provide insight regarding the seismic safety of buildings having similar conditions.