Battle of the Styles? Classical and Gothic Architecture in Seventeenth-Century North-East England

Research over the last twenty years into seventeenth-century elite British architecture has questioned the view that Classical designs were the preserve of a narrow group of royal and aristocratic patrons at the Stuart court, and also that Inigo Jones was a ‘lonely genius' misunderstood in his own lifetime but prophesizing the true Classicism that was to bloom in the eighteenth century.

The role of patrons in defining architectural styles has also been analysed, and it has been noted that Classicism was not the only style they favoured. For earlier historians, a perception that Classical architecture was an advance upon the Gothic style of medieval English buildings led to discussions of ‘Gothic survival' or ‘Gothic revival' and of a ‘Battle of the Styles' in sixteenth-, seventeenth- and eighteenth-century buildings, with such patrons as Lady Anne Clifford (1590–1676), who commissioned and renovated buildings in Gothic style, being viewed as a ‘curiosity' for not employing Classical style.